If you fish the Raritan Bay area I highly recommend the Atlantic Star out of Atlantic Highlands. Great Capt. and crew. Melissa and I have fished on this boat quite a few times and we have been very happy with results. If you are in south Jersey like we are I can honestly say it's worth the drive up there once in a while to fish with these guys.
Do let this one go. Capt Mike and his mate Capt Chris do a great job fishing the back bays on the High Roller He fishes for blues early in the spring then Fluke all summer before switching to stripers in the fall. Crowd is fun. Capt is funnier.
Melissa and I fished aboard the Miss Avalon for the first time yesterday and we had a good time. It was a mixed bag of mostly Black Sea Bass, Fluke and Trigger fish. Keepers were hard to come by but a fair number of fish were caught. Melissa won the pool with a hefty Sea Bass that was also her biggest fish so far. The Captain did a good job as did the crew. The boat was nice and clean and obviously well maintained. I would go out on the Miss Avalon again any time.